• Media & Diversity
  • About
    • DONOR TRANSPARENCY POLICY
  • Digital Jobs
    • Aunt Benet’s Career Advice
    • Media Movers
  • Resources
    • Fellowships & Rewards
  • Advertise
    • Rate Card
  • Contact Us

All Digitocracy

Media & Diversity

  • NEWS
  • BUSINESS
  • INTERNATIONAL
  • POLICY
  • AllD TECH
  • PEOPLE
  • ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT

Guilty: Olympic Games are tarnished by media coverage that is often sexist and racist

August 16, 2016 by Tracy Everbach

Gymnast Simone Biles has been a star in the Olympic Games, but instead of saluting her hard work, some reporters insinuate she has an advantage because of what they call “inhuman athletic talent”

Gold medal winner Simone Biles, women and other athletes of color are often discredited for their hard work as journalists unfairly insinuate they have an advatage because of their genes.

Gold medal winner Simone Biles, women and other athletes of color are often discredited for their hard work.

The day after gymnast Simone Biles won a gold medal in Rio, the front-page headline in my local newspaper celebrated her as “Superlative Simone.” But I did a double-take when I saw a column headline underneath that read, “ ‘I don’t think she’s human,’ rival says of dominant Texas gymnast.”

How could those words have sailed past the editors? Insinuating in a headline that a black woman is something other than human hearkens back to the days of slavery, when black people in America were considered three-fifths of a human being. (See your history book for the 3/5 Compromise from 1787). It also evokes persistent stereotypes of African American women.

I understand the sports connotation in the quote — that the athlete is better at her sport than any other human—but the historical context makes this headline demeaning.

An academic term called incognizant racism can explain some of the racist and sexist coverage we have seen in the 2016 Summer Olympics. The term refers to an unintentional bias on the part of journalists, who adopt the dominant white and male values of society and pass them along to the public through daily coverage. We have seen several examples of this phenomenon in the Olympics. Consider:

  • The San Jose Mercury News had to apologize after tweeting “Michael Phelps shares historic night with African-American,” in reference to the gold medal won by U.S. swimmer Simone Manuel, whose name was not even mentioned in the original headline. Twitter followers called out the tweet as racist and sexist.
  • The Chicago Tribune tweeted that “wife of a Bears’ (sic) lineman” — with no name — won a medal when Corey Cogdell won the bronze in women’s trap shooting. Social media critics noted that Cogdell has a name other than “wife” and that she won a medal for her athletic ability, not her marital role.
  • NBC commentators have been called out on social media for reinforcing sexist stereotypes. Examples: describing the USA “Final Five” gymnastics team as “they might as well be standing in the middle of a mall” and giving credit to the husband/coach of Hungarian swimmer Katinka Hosszu for her breaking a world record.
  • Scottish tennis player Andy Murray corrected a BBC host who congratulated him on “being the first person ever to win two Olympic tennis gold medals” by snapping back: “I think Venus and Serena won about four each.
  • The male athletes have not been exempt either, with NBC anchors Meredith Vieira and Hoda Kotb virtually drooling over an oiled-up Tongan flag-bearer and magazines running headlines such as “36 Summer Olympics bulges that deserve gold” (Cosmopolitan.com). (I’m not hyperlinking to those—you can find them).

Objectification — reducing people to their body parts—is dehumanizing. However, it’s much worse for women than men, since a long tradition of media coverage has focused on their appearances, their relationships to men, or their roles as wives and mothers (can you imagine the headline “Father of Two Signs Bill into Law?”). On the positive side, social media has made it easier for the public to hold media organizations accountable for spreading sexism and racism.

But when newsrooms still are 87 percent white, 63 percent male, and 90 percent of sports sections are headed by white men, it’s going to take more effort for media organizations to avoid harmful and degrading coverage. Awareness is step No. 1. Here’s hoping newsroom leaders will move forward to the next step.

Tracy Everbach is associate professor of journalism at the University of North Texas and a former newspaper reporter.

Filed Under: Featured, JOURNALISM, NEWS Tagged With: 2016 Olympics, media, Olympics, Simone Biles

What journalists are missing about Simone Manuel’s historic win

August 12, 2016 by Cynthia Liu

Here’s why that tweet from the San Jose Mercury News is such a slap in the face to black women in America. To black people in America, period.

Simone Manuel

This isn’t a commentary on the overall inept Olympics coverage by NBC of African American swimmer and gold medalist Simone Manuel’s historic win— the network missed WHY her win is historic. In fact, journalists everywhere are missing the point. And we won’t even elaborate on that offensive tweet initially posted by The San Jose Mercury News in which the news organization identified her only as an “African American.”

Here’s what is being left out: The racial history of American swimming pools.

Dorothy Dandridge was a beautiful singer and dancer who performed in the most exclusive nightclubs and hotels in the country, but couldn’t get a room in any of them, or even use the pools. Night clubs were happy to have her, and other black performers, to entertain white patrons, but only if they came and went through the back door and didn’t use the bathrooms. Introducing Dorothy Dandridge, an HBO movie, based on her life story, contains a gut-wrenching scene in which Dandridge dips her toe into a Las Vegas hotel pool, which is then drained and scrubbed– by black maintenance workers.

The San Jose Mercury News initially only identified Simone Manuel as “an African American.” The organization later apologized, sending out a new tweet.

Tell the whole story. Give the context that is the backstory to Manuel’s historic win.

Journalists need to tell this story, and yes, also include her commentary on today’s ‪#‎blacklivesmatters‬ movement in all interviews a groundbreaking woman of color gold medalist is expected to give knowing that she has a global platform.

Do better, NBC News. Do better other journalists in general. I know you have a gazillion and one researchers, video archivists, journalists and editors who can understand this. <insert snark>

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cynthia LiuCynthia Liu is the founder of K-12 News Network, an award-winning civic tech grassroots education website. She is also a political blogger and lives in Los Angeles with her husband and son.

Filed Under: Ethics, Featured, JOURNALISM, NEWS, Newspapers, Online, PEOPLE, Television Tagged With: Dorothy Dandridge, nbc, Olympics, San Jose Mercury News, Simone Manuel

Follow @allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

Join me for this event: The Financial Future of Local News #trustinnews https://t.co/8ax0gMuU0Q.
View on Twitter
0
0
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

Starting with its November issue, @NatGeo is launching a year of celebrating the power of women’s voices and how they’re changing the world. https://t.co/tJzTlTNeZ8
View on Twitter
allDigitocracy photo
2
1
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

After months of financial struggle, Howard's student newspaper is considering going online-only.
https://t.co/IVfz2khAIY
View on Twitter
0
0
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

Missed yesterday's webinar on the new Racial Equity in Journalism Fund? Watch it now and then apply! https://t.co/HiAJSXij7L
View on Twitter
1
0
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

Botham Jean, Amber Guyger and the urgent case for unconscious bias training... https://t.co/Tnob4G2uEp on @bloglovin
View on Twitter
0
0
allDigitocracy
allDigitocracy @allDigitocracy

#BothamJean, #AmberGuyger and the case for unconscious bias training in U.S. newsrooms. https://t.co/yaOvnTWDni https://t.co/Zgp3cUFtVX
View on Twitter
allDigitocracy photo
1
0

Copyright © 2019 · allDigitocracy on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in